Welcome to a few of our new subscribers!
Joshua Miller of “Human Intelligence Brief” fame
Amelia Mysiak, with the upcoming “Common Practice”
Dr. Allen Lycka, who was told he had 6 months to live and didn’t agree
Natty, the mama of 2
And Jane Kisnica, designer extraordinaire
When I was 22 years old, I managed to get an interview with the CEO of Geffen Records.
This wasn’t just any record company. It was Geffen fucking Records. Guns N’ Roses, Nirvana, Elton John, John Lennon.
The coolest company around. The one place I’d dreamed of working.
I’d written a letter to the CEO from my college dorm room, dropped it in the mail, and somehow convinced him to give me a shot.
It must’ve been one helluva letter.
So shortly after graduation, I crammed my belongings into my VW Rabbit and drove from Connecticut to Los Angeles.
No job. No apartment. No connections. I didn’t even have a backup plan.
All I had was one interview and a dream.
The interview with the CEO, Eddie Rosenblatt, went great.
That is, until we got into the argument.
He asked me a question.
I answered.
He disagreed.
Keep in mind, Eddie had 25 years of leadership experience in the music industry and ran one of the most successful record companies in the world.
I was a 22-year-old kid whose biggest professional accomplishment thus far was getting someone to answer a letter.
You’d think I’d consider his perspective.
Nope. Not me.
Instead, I told the CEO of Geffen Records that he was wrong. Because that seemed like the smart thing for me to do.
When Eddie pushed back on me, I pushed back harder.
This won’t come as a surprise, but I didn’t get the job. I never even spoke with Eddie again.
All in all, I drove across country to convince the CEO of Geffen Records to hire me. Instead, I tried to convince him he was an idiot.
But here’s the really screwed-up part.
I wasn’t trying to be difficult.
I genuinely believed I was right.
And being convinced I was right made it almost impossible for me to consider that I might be wrong.
Turns out, this isn’t just a problem for cocky 22-year-olds.
It’s probably also a problem for you.
You Hired A Really Expensive Audience
As an executive coach and CEO coach, I’ve worked with some incredibly smart, successful leaders.
They’ve built businesses, managed thousands of employees, and made decisions involving millions of dollars.
They know their stuff.
I know they know their stuff.
And they know I know they know that they know their stuff.
But knowing your stuff can turn into a liability.
For instance, I’ve watched leaders hire incredibly talented people, pay them six-figure salaries, and then spend half their meetings explaining why those same people are wrong.
Think about how ridiculous that is.
You hire smart people.
Tell them you value their opinions.
Then, when they challenge your thinking, you explain why their opinions are bad.
You hire people because they’re smart. Then you spend your time proving you’re smarter.
Eventually, those smart people will stop sharing their ideas. Not because they don’t have any. But because you’ve taught them that you don’t want to hear them.
But wait, there’s more…
The leader usually interprets their silence as proof that nobody else in the company has any good ideas. Which, of course, just reinforces their belief that they need to have all the answers.
This is the Pattern-Environment Loop, and it’s usually the point when I get a call.
The leaders who do this, the ones who feel a need to be the smartest person in the room, rarely think they’re being defensive. Instead, they think they’re being helpful. After all, they’re protecting the business from bad decisions.
And sometimes they’re even right.
But when you believe you’re protecting the business, it’s really hard to recognize that you might actually just be protecting your identity.
You’re Not Defending the Idea Anymore
Early in your career, you’re rewarded for learning.
Later, you’re rewarded for knowing.
Somewhere along the way, knowing becomes part of who you are.
So when somebody challenges your idea, it doesn’t feel like they’re questioning your thinking. It feels like they’re questioning you.
Naturally, you defend yourself.
Except you don’t call it defending. You call it “sharing your expertise.”
And you probably have no idea you’re doing it.
That's exactly how something that made you successful starts making you less effective.
In fact, this is something I’ve been writing about in my book, Why Nothing Sticks.
You promise yourself that you’ll listen more, be more open-minded, stop getting defensive, or whatever the behavior is that you want to change.
And for a while, you do.
But then someone inevitably challenges your beliefs. And suddenly that new behavior disappears into the ether and you’re back to your regular old ways of reacting.
You can’t fix an identity problem by white-knuckling a behavioral change.
You’ve become so good at being right, you’ve forgotten how to be wrong.
The Last Time Someone Disagreed With You
Here’s a little experiment.
Think about the last time someone challenged an idea you felt strongly about.
Do you have one? Is it in your head?
Ok, now think about what your reaction was.
Did you genuinely try to understand the other person’s perspective?
Or were you just waiting for them to stop talking so you could explain why they were wrong?
Mmm-hmmm.
So here’s something I want you to try.
The next time someone disagrees with you about something important, don’t explain why they’re wrong.
Instead, ask them to explain why they think they’re right.
Then shut up and listen.
In fact, don’t even suggest your opinion until you can explain their idea well enough that they’d agree you’ve understood it.
You don’t have to think their idea is wonderful.
You don’t even have to change your mind.
You just have to be willing to consider that they might know something you don’t.
The Worst Argument I Ever Won
I still don’t know whether I was right or wrong in that interview with Eddie Rosenblatt.
Maybe I was right.
Maybe he was.
Maybe we were both full of crap.
But here’s what I know.
I walked into his office wanting a job. And I walked out having defended an opinion.
Somewhere along the way, I lost sight of what actually mattered.
I don’t regret disagreeing with him.
Having more experience or a bigger title doesn’t automatically make someone right.
What I do regret is that I was so busy trying to prove I was right that I never bothered to find out whether he might be.
Because being wrong doesn’t make you a bad leader.
Being unwilling to find out does.
P.S. I’ve thought about that interview a lot over the years. I still don’t know if Eddie was right. I reached out to him later in my career but never got the chance to talk. And then I screwed up that whole thing with Jimmy Iovine.





Jeff, your honesty makes this lesson stick. The distinction between protecting the business and protecting our identity is such a useful leadership mirror. I especially appreciate the practical challenge to understand another person’s reasoning well enough to explain it back. That kind of humility makes room for the whole team’s intelligence. Strong piece.